50/50 Child Access: A Passionate and Heated Debate

A poll conducted by Divorce Magazine shows the opinions of divorce professionals and people going through divorce alike on whether custody should start with a 50/50 split. The results were gathered and reported by Josh Simon.

By Josh Simon
July 31, 2010

Divorce Magazine conducted a poll at www.DivorceMagazine.com and used social media channels, such as LinkedIn and our blog, to gauge public opinion on this controversial topic: should 50/50 custody be the starting point in divorce law, and only adjusted based on special circumstances (e.g. abuse). As expected, feedback was and remains varied, impassioned and thought-provoking. The poll results, and a very small sampling of the hundreds of comments we’ve received from a range of divorce professionals and divorcing individuals are provided below.

Child Custody

FOR

"50/50 should be the presumption for custody, regardless of parental ability and the children's needs." - Family Lawyer in Washington D.C.

"Since during a marriage, parents are joint legal custodians of their children, this arrangement should remain unchanged upon its dissolution - unless of course there are conditions that would make joint custody unworkable." - Canadian Trial Consultant

"In the Nordic countries we have had joint custody for many years. It was introduced in Iceland in 1992, Denmark in 1995, Norway in 1997 and Sweden in 1998. A few parents can´t handle it, but the general opinion is, that it works well, so just move on." - Denmark Attorney

From individuals across the web come the following comments:

"I agree it should be 50/50…as women we didn’t create [children] by ourselves and why would we want to raise them ourselves?"

"For those of us who are great dads, we should get to start with 50/50 so the mom doesn't have a totally unfair advantage to begin with. I shouldn't have to prove I deserve my kids; you should have to prove I don't."

AGAINST

"Anger, hurt, frustration, rejection, resentment and blaming usually occur due to unresolved issues. All of these factors escalate while trying to reach an agreement and usually continues post divorce. This happens when the couple does not make any emotional progress or come to terms with their situation. Co-parenting or 50/50 custody becomes difficult and sometimes impossible." - Florida-area licensed Clinical Social Worker

"Stop and think about your daily life. Do you work? What are your hours? Even though I live with my daughter and Wife, I do not spend 50% of my time with her. I see her for an hour in the morning and an hour or two at night. I try to get my clients to focus on the quality of time rather than the quantity of time." – New York Divorce Attorney

Additionally, divorced/divorcing individuals have been forthcoming and candid with their views.

"How do you ask for 50/50 custody when you are currently not even being ‘bothered’ with you child?"

"I don't think 50/50's what's best for the kids. They need a "home" they're in/at the majority of the time. They need ONE school district, etc. The more normalcy, routine, predictability, and stability they can have in their lives, the better."

Results of Online Survey at www.divorcemag.com:
Though the poll results point to a consensus in favor of the idea, the issue is fraught with complexity and has many layers that relate to legal and non-legal aspects. "Do you think that 50/50 custody should be the starting point in divorce law, and only adjusted based on special circumstances (e.g. abuse)?" (Gina, this needs to be in bold)
  • Overall: 74% say yes; 26% say no
  • Women: 64% say yes; 36% say no
  • Men: 88% say yes; 12% say no
This poll was conducted between Jan and May 2010 and received 1,166 total votes. For more information on this poll, visit http://www.divorcemag.com/poll_results.php

We’d like to hear your thoughts on this and other critical issues. To read comments and share your views please:


For more articles on child custody and divorce, visit
www.divorcemag.com/articles/Child_Custody

Back To Top

July 31, 2010

Add A Comment

Comment

Allowed HTML: <b>, <i>, <u>, <a>

Comments

 

Reason for your Divorce

Why did your relationship end? If there's more than one reason, choose the strongest factor.

Money Problems/Arguments
Physical/Emotional Infidelity
Physical/Mental Illness
Physical/Emotional Abuse
Alcoholism/Addiction Issues
Basic Incompatibility


Copyright © 2014 Divorce Magazine, Divorce Marketing Group & Segue Esprit Inc. All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without prior written permission is prohibited.

 2014